Drafting the Nation
As the Framers drafted different versions of our founding documents, their ideas of what it meant to be a republic also changed. In this unit, four lessons based on the drafts of the Articles of Confederation, Declaration of Independence, and the Constitution, held at the collection at HSP, allow students to explore the language and ideas behind these pivotal documents. Starting with the Declaration of Independence, students will discover how language and words can represent larger ideas while trying to figure out how Jefferson wanted this masterpiece to be heard aloud. Moving into the Articles of Confederation, students will compare and contrast a draft with the final version to identify not only the strengths and weakness of this document but also the evolving perception the Framers had of themselves and the Republic’s identity during the Age of Revolution. Finally, the students will encounter two lessons concerning the United States Constitution. The first lesson will introduce them to the overarching ideas of the Seven Principles, and the second will build upon some of those principles by examining the Preamble in both a draft form and its final version.
Government and civics
What document or artifact best summarizes the United States and why?
What role does analysis have in historical construction?
Background Material for Teacher
Preserving American Freedom – Historical Society of Pennsylvania website with Founding documents
Early Drafts of the U.S. Constitution – William Ewald, and Lorianne Updike Toler. "Early Drafts of the U.S. Constitution." The Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 135, no. 3 (2011): 227-38. doi:10.5215/pennmaghistbio.135.3.0227.
Defending the Articles of Confederation: A Response to Sobel – Dougherty, Keith L. "Defending the Articles of Confederation: A Response to Sobel." Public Choice 109, no. 1/2 (2001): 141-48. http://www.jstor.org/stable/30026480.
The Declaration of Independence: How Did it Happen? - Website by the National Archives
End of Unit Assessment
Each Lesson has its own Assessment:
Declaration of Independence
Part A - To wrap-up this section of the activity, students “Give the Declaration of Independence a Tweet":
no more than 140 characters
tweet @someone (maybe the King of England)
Use one #hashtag for the whole document
Create a twitter ‘handle’ the Founders would have
Part B - Wrap-up this activity by having the students write a paragraph reflecting on why they think the Declaration of Independence has endured this long and is one of the most influential documents in modern world history.
Articles of Confederation
Have students use materials created during the lesson, to write an essay, using examples from the text, explaining the weakness of the Articles of Confederation, how this document distributes power between the state and national governments, and why they think the framers distributed power in this way instead of centralizing it in a big Federal government.
As an Exit Ticket, students will write down their favorite principle), what that principle means, and why it is their favorite.
As an Exit Tickets, students will write answers to these prompts:
What is the single most important change the Founders made to the Preamble and why?
What is the purpose of the Preamble to the United States Constitution?
Plans in this Unit
PA Core Standards
About the Author
This lesson was created by Brendon Floyd, Education Intern at the Historical Society of Pennsylvania
Let us know how you used this plan and be featured on our site! Submit your story here.